Dear Experts,

Hope you are fine. I want to know that is there a method by which we can know that where should we attach the weight or which location should we add support to stiffen the structure to change it natural frequency. I heard somewhere that there are nodes and anti-nodes by which we can know where to make modification. Is it possible to know by just using our analyzer and vibration sensors? Or it is only possible by ODS or Modal Analysis in FEA software?

Best Regards,
Original Post

Abdullah - The theory is fairly simple to explain but not always so easy to put into practice.

If we are talking about a SDOF structure, we generally want to raise stiffness, increase k, so that Fn is outside/above the speed of the forcing frequency (oftentimes running speed). This is usually preferred since it avoids being excited during startup. Adding mass will lower Fn, sometimes used in fixed-speed machines. Which to use for your particular case depends on a lot of factors and can't be answered simply with the information you provide.

To be effective, knowing where to add stiffness or add mass is important. Modifications at nodal points (locations where there is little motion) would not be effective.

You can "visualize" how the structure moves without the need of sophisticated ODS or FEA models. You can take data during operation (preferably amplitude AND phase) along the structure and plot out its motion; or a bump test when machine is not running.

Having said all this, there are a number of issues you should be aware of before you recommend a fix:  Adding stiffness will usually add mass - which can be self-defeating; What is the exciting force and is it at a single frequency or does the machine have a range of speeds; Do you suspect it is a simple reed motion or something more complex?, etc. 

Others on this forum can also elaborate. I would suggest you dig deeper into this so you fully understand the problem based on your comment, "....I heard somewhere there are nodes and anti-nodes..."

Regards    Jim P

Last edited by ivibr8

I agree with Jim P, You may want to consider bringing in an experienced analyst to help identify the path to correction. Often when changes are considered it should be checked/verified by a Mechanical Engineer/Structural Engineer to avoid causing other problems within the machine. 

If you don't understand "Nodes and Anti-Nodes" it sounds like you are over you head in understanding the complexity of the problem. 

Add Reply

Link copied to your clipboard.